You've been reforging accessories wrong.

Image of eater of worlds boss from terraria

How is it menacing? Lol : r/Terraria

r/Terraria 🌳 on X: So me and my friend did a duo summoned build through Master Mode. All of our equipment was reforged to Menacing;) / X

Steam Community :: Guide :: Lucky vs Menacing Modifiers: A Critical Analysis

The three Nocturnal Mechanical Menaces [Terraria] by Colsjin on DeviantArt

Menacing huh? : r/Terraria

tfw you have reforge all of your accessories from lucky to menacing because *too* much luck is a concept that apparently exists : r/Terraria

What was planted in faith? Let's not Dig Up in Terraria! - Page 3 - Brontoforumus

Legendary Orc: Menacing Monster with Detailed Armor - Fantasy Poster for Sale by Just Art's Creations colinw2292@gmail.com

Let's Play Terraria 1.2.4 Part 64!: MENACING FERAL CLAWS!